|
About DNA and Chromosomes
The Paternity
Testing Process
Accuracy of a Paternity
Test
1.
About DNA and Chromosomes
DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is the genetic blueprint of life.
It determines the specific characteristics or traits of each individual.
Except for identical twins, every person's DNA is unique. Consequently,
a unique genetic profile can be created from a person's DNA. This
DNA profile can identify the individual uniquely, and forms the
basis of the paternity test.
DNA is a long threadlike
molecule found in almost all cells of the human body. An individual's
genetic makeup is coded within the DNA in several functional units
called genes. The entire DNA content of practically all cells is
located in 46 chromosomes. These are complex molecular structures
consisting of a long DNA strand and a framework of associated proteins.
The chromosomes are grouped
into 23 pairs, of which 22 pairs are homologous, meaning that the
paired chromosomes are of the same size and appearance and store
information related to the same inherited traits. The 23rd pair
comprises the sex chromosomes that are important for sex determination.
Each set of 23 chromosomes is inherited from one biological parent.
Thus, every individual has two genetic complements in their DNA,
one complement inherited from the biological mother and the other
from the biological father. This fact forms the foundation on which
DNA paternity testing is based, since it allows the biological relationship
between a child and an alleged father to be validated or excluded
by a comparison of their DNA.
back to top
2.
The Paternity Testing Process
In the previous section it was established that by comparing the
DNA of a child and an alleged father, it is possible investigate
their biological relationship. In practice, only certain regions
in the DNA, called microsatellite markers or loci, need to be compared
to establish biological paternity. Microsatellite markers are short
fragments of DNA in which the same DNA sequence is repeated several
times. Since an individual has two genetic complements of DNA, there
are actually two copies of each marker present, one inherited from
each of the biological parents.
Depending on the laboratory,
generally between 10 and 16 microsatellite markers are analysed
for determination of paternity. The microsatellite markers used
are standard markers recommended by specialised organisations such
as the European Network of Forensic Science (ENFSI), the Iberoamerican
Working Group on DNA Analysis (GITAD), and Interpol. An important
property of these markers is that the number of DNA sequence repetitions
(or frequency) is highly variable within the general population
but strongly conserved from parent to child. As a result, the frequency
of one complement of each of the child's markers matches that of
one complement of the biological mother, whereas the frequency of
the other complement matches that of one complement of the biological
father (see Example 1).
The set of frequencies
of the analysed markers constitutes the genetic profile of a tested
individual. A standard paternity test determines the genetic profiles
of the mother, the child and the alleged father. By comparing the
three profiles it is possible to identify the marker in each complementary
pair that the child inherited from the biological mother. By elimination,
the remaining half of the genetic profile was inherited from the
biological father. By comparing this part of the child's genetic
profile with the profile of the alleged father, the Paternity Test
determines whether the alleged father is the biological father or
not. A match between the two profiles indicates that the alleged
father is the real biological father (Example 1). On the other hand,
if the profile of the alleged father does not match that of the
child, he is excluded from paternity (Example 2).
back to top
3. Accuracy of a Paternity
Test
Since it is so specific,
DNA
paternity testing is a very powerful form of testing. In a test
including samples from the mother, child and alleged father, the
probability of paternity is 99.99% or greater when an alleged father's
DNA profile matches that of the child for all the genetic markers.
On the other hand, an alleged father is 100% excluded from paternity
if there is a mismatch between the profiles of the child and alleged
father for three or more genetic markers.
When only a child
and alleged father are tested (i.e. a motherless test), the information
provided by the mother's
DNA
profile is unavailable. Nonetheless, when there is a perfect
match between the
DNA
profiles of the child and alleged father, the probability of
paternity is generally in excess of 99.99%. A mismatch in the two
DNA profiles for three or more genetic markers implies with 100%
certainty that the alleged father is not the child's biological
father.
The accuracy of the
test increases with the number of genetic markers included in the
DNA profile. Thus, the result of a test that uses a 16-marker profile
is likely to be more conclusive than one using a 6- or 13-marker
profile. It is therefore important to select a paternity test that
uses an adequate number of markers, especially when only the child
and alleged father are tested.
Since family members
are more likely to have similar genetic profiles, when two alleged
fathers are related the probability of paternity may be lower than
in standard tests. In such cases it is always best to test both
alleged fathers, since the one who is not the biological father
can be excluded with certainty. If the two alleged fathers are identical
twins it is not possible to identify the biological father, since
identical twins have identical
DNA
profiles.
The reason that it
is not possible to determine biological paternity with 100% certainty
is that there is always a very small possibility that the profile
of the alleged father matches that of the child purely by chance.
The likelihood of this happening is generally well below 0.001%
(or 1 in 100000) and it depends to a large extent on the ethnic
origin of the individuals involved. The certainty of biological
paternity generally increases with the number of genetic markers
analysed.
4. Example 1

Case 1: The figure
shows the result for one microsatellite marker from a paternity
test that includes samples from the mother (top row), the child
(middle row), and the alleged father (bottom row). In this example,
the maternal marker that has been passed to the child is number
6. This means that the other marker present for the child (number
7) must have been inherited from the father. In this case the alleged
father matches the child, since one of his markers is indeed number
7. This procedure is repeated for all microsatellite markers used
in the test.
5. Example 2
Case 2: The figure
shows the result for one microsatellite marker from a paternity
test that includes samples from the mother (top row), the child
(middle row), and the alleged father (bottom row). In this case
the maternal markers are 29 and 30. This implies that the child
has inherited 29 from the mother and the 31.2 complement must have
been inherited from the biological father. Since the alleged father
does not possess this marker it is unlikely that he is the biological
father. In practice this mismatch between the child and alleged
father's DNA must be present in at least three markers to exclude
paternity with certainty.
back
to top
|